In a number of blog posts I have spelled out precisely what a recovery means -- not a return to "normal" times, but a period where the overall level of economic activity is rising. The pace of the recovery ultimately determines how long it will take to return to "normal" times or to peak levels from the prior recovery for key indicators.
Over the past four months, employment in Rhode Island has turned in a surprisingly strong performance. On a year-over-year basis, while job loss has remained roughly constant, job gains have clearly accelerated (see blog post on this). The result is important enough to show the following graph again here (click to enlarge).
I used the median for this since the extreme values of layoffs during the last recession would push the mean significantly higher. The median, which is the middle value when all values are arranged in ascending order, will not get "pulled" higher as the mean would, so it is the preferred measure of "central tendency" here.
Three important points need to be made about the indicators reflected in these graphs. First, layoffs (actually New Claims for Unemployment Insurance), which is one of the indicators in my Current Conditions Index, is a leading economic indicator. This means that its changes today signal future movements in the overall level of economic activity. So, declining layoffs signal that Rhode Island's economy has been gaining momentum of late. Second, payroll employment overall, or its components, job gain and job loss, are coincident indicators, meaning that their changes reflect the current performance of the overall economy. From the first chart, the acceleration of job gain relative to job loss confirms what the recent downtrend in layoffs implies, that Rhode Island's overall economic performance is improving. Finally, since Rhode Island has income and sales taxes, improving levels of overall economic activity, which produce higher levels of income, result in added income and sales tax revenue. This is the basis for the recent "surprises" in tax revenue our state has witnessed.
What about the fact that Rhode Island's unemployment rate has remained stuck around 11 percent as these changes in layoffs and job gains have been occurring? While everyone pays a great deal of attention to the unemployment rate, it doesn't always move in lockstep with changes in payroll employment, for several reasons. Among other things, it is derived from a separate labor market survey, the household survey. And, the unemployment rate is a lagging indicator, so its changes now reflect what has occurred in past months. There is also a strange footnote to the way the unemployment rate is calculated: unemployed persons who stop actively seeking work are not counted as being part of the labor force, therefore they are excluded from the monthly unemployment number. The flip side of this is that when an economy improves, and some of the unemployed who had stopped looking for work begin once again to search for employment, they are now counted as part of the labor force, which tends to cause a short-term rise in the unemployment rate. However, recent declines in Rhode Island's jobless rate have largely been the result of our unemployed ceasing job search. So, it is quite possible that Rhode Island's unemployment rate might actually rise before it resumes declines based on the behavior of layoffs and job gains discussed above.
Let me point out a strange element of Rhode Island's current economic climate. Our state's jobless rate was third highest in the nation in May. Yet in spite of having so many unemployed persons here, and such a high unemployment rate, manufacturing wage growth has been very strong. While this signals recent manufacturing strength here, it also reflects the existence of skill shortages. Go figure!
Finally, at the same time Rhode Island's economy has experienced this enhanced cyclical momentum, a substantial number of structural negatives, most notably the lack of skills of our labor force, have offset some or much of this cyclical momentum. That explains why this recovery doesn't necessarily feel all that different from being in a recession.
EPILOGUE: After posting this last evening (7/7), the June payroll employment report for the US came out this morning. The results took everyone (including me) by surprise, as national employment rose by only 18,000, well below prior expectations. It will be very interesting to see the June numbers for Rhode Island when they are released in a few weeks. If they show no employment pause here, I will have to question the last few months of data here. I'll have a lot more to say on this if it actually occurs.
No comments:
Post a Comment